Residents of City View and surrounding neighborhoods will soon receive ballots in their mail. Please follow this link to the Ottawa City website that provides detailed information on the levy and the vote:
progress is being made with the efforts to acquire the heritage house
(Kilmorie) and the surrounding property for community use at 21 Withrow Avenue.The
developer, Joey Theberge, has given us until April 15 to raise the money needed
to purchase the house and property at 21 Withrow After that date, he will start to build the
4 houses on Withrow. Then he will build
the subdivision of 9 more houses.
Homes is now the owner of the entire estate.
Mr. Theberge has been very cooperative in giving us another opportunity
to save this property. However, this is
the last chance.
We have met with the City of Ottawa Officials
and have been advised that the only opportunity to raise the necessary financing
is by way of a levy on community property taxes.
City Councillor Scott Moffatt has kindly
agreed to represent us and help us through this process. The proposal for a levy will cover the area
of City View, Crestview Meadowlands and Ryan Farm. The commercial properties in this area will
also pay into the levy.
will be a public meeting on Thursday, February 6 at City View United Church at
7pm. A notice of this meeting will be
mailed out shortly.
are many benefits for the local communities with this proposal. The City would own the property but it would
be available for community use. This is
an opportunity to have a Community Centre and attached passive pleasure park
with historical flower gardens in our community. There would be no cars permitted in the
park. This certainly would enhance our
community and create a place for us to gather and to come together. This would be a significant overall
improvement to our neighbourhoods. More
details of this will be presented at the meeting.
are actual cost details that are being worked out. The federal and provincial governments as
well as private donations and grants have money that can be available. The City of Ottawa must own the property before
we can apply for these grants.
more information, please attend the meeting or contact us at:
firstname.lastname@example.org to ask any questions. Watch our web page: ourcityview.ca and find
us on Facebook.
let your neighbours, even those who may not be members of our association, know
of the efforts being made on this important project.
Posted inUncategorized|Comments Off on SAVING KILMORIE AT 21 WITHROW
On Nov. 14, the Ottawa planning committee met and approved the proposed development on the site of Kilmorie (21 Withrow Ave). The development will go forward if approved by full council on Nov 27. Read the response from Kilmorie Heritage Foundation below.
Dear Mayor Watson and City of Ottawa Councillors:
Former American First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy and many other individuals saved Grand Central Station in New York City. Mrs. Kennedy wrote a letter to Mayor Beame:
“Is it not cruel to let our city die by degrees, stripped of her proud moments, until there is nothing left of all her history and beauty to inspire our children?… If they are not inspired by the past of our city, where will they find the strength to fight for her future?”
On Wednesday, November 27, 2019, the Planning Committee will be presenting to City Council an application, that they approved, to build a subdivision at 21 Withrow. The motion to approve this application at the Planning Committee on November 14, 2019, was based on flawed and biased statements by Parks and Heritage City staff. The City View Community Association and the Kilmorie Heritage Society had no opportunity to demonstrate to this Committee the correct facts. Please see attached “Letter of Rebuttal”.
Over the last few years, City View has met with our Councillor and Parks staff to state the deficit of parkland that exists in our community. But still today, we hear the same flawed facts presented by the city. Please see also the attached two pictures of Bassano Park, one of the three parks listed in City View. Please also see the attached report on the deficit of parks in City View.
The heritage value of the house has been approved by the Heritage staff at City Hall. The property was not included, due to many extenuating circumstances. This subdivision will forever hide this landmark from the view of all. It will be hidden in an elite subdivision of million dollar homes on a private road. This is a case of poor development and over development.
The preservation of this greenspace seems to be a priority in the City’s new Official Plan. But it will be too late. The greenspace and trees will be lost forever.
“Grand Central Terminal stands as a universal symbol between New York City’s past and present.”
Kilmorie house and nature park, with gardens filled with heirloom flowers and plants, a block off the intensified Merivale Road, should be a universal symbol between our past and our future. It should not be a subdivision with million dollar homes. This subdivision has NO benefits for City View and the surrounding communities.
Will there be any Councillor on Wednesday, November 27, who will stand up and say that this subdivision is wrong?
President, Kilmorie Heritage Society
President, City View Community Association
Letter of rebuttal:
November 20, 2019
Harder and Members of the Planning Committee:
attended the Planning Committee Meeting, on Thursday, November 14, 2019, to
oppose the current proposed development at 21 Withrow Avenue. We found the meeting to be respectful and
well managed. All the presentations
given by the members of
the public were opposed to this development.
presentations, a single representation was made by the Consulting Firm on behalf of the developer.
pertinent questions were then asked by several Councillors. These were directed to the
consultant, Jonah Bonn; Jennifer Shepherd, Program
Manager, Parks and Facilities Planning Services and
Sally Coutts, Co-ordinator, Heritage Service from the Planning,
Infrastructure and Economic Development Department.
The answers given
by these people were misleading or false.
In specific situations, the questions by the Councillor were
not answered directly as the City’s representative basically changed the subject. The members of the community observing at the back of the room felt an urgent need to rebut these points, but were too
polite to disrupt the meeting.
Here are the
points of our rebuttal:
Chairperson Harder announced the
developer, Joey Theberge, as the owner of said property.
On Page 3 of the application, the
Planning Department states that Joey Theberge is the owner of the property.
The fact that the ownership is stated to be Joey Theberge is
incorrect. It is very misleading to the
public. The owners are still the Roger
the question about a fair price for the property could be directed to the
current owners, since Mr. Theberge could not answer this. This question should
be answered before the development is approved.
Jonah Bonn, Holzman Consulting
Mr. Bonn states that the cost to
rehabilitate the heritage house would be up to $400 000 for the house and $100
000 for the garage. Please understand
that the house will be gutted inside and modernized. The garage will be
demolished and rebuilt. This is NOT the
intention of the Kilmorie Heritage Society and the City View Community
Association. Our intention is to save the inside of the
house to reflect the era in which it was
built. We have met with our MP Anita
Vandenbeld, who will help us to apply for grants for this purpose from the
Federal Government. We have approached
Algonquin College to be partners in this rehabilitation project. However, both parties require the purchase of
the property before proceeding with any agreement.
Mr. Bonn was questioned about the proposed tree
conservation plan through preserving and
replanting. Specifically he was asked
about the trees in the centre of the property and the trees lining the border
on Withrow Avenue. Mr. Bonn stated that he was not a landscaper. However, an examination of the
proposed plans demonstrates that ALL the trees on the
edge of the property will be cut down.
There will be very few trees saved in the centre of this property because
the developer proposes to construct large milliondollar
homes on very small lots. Trees are
obviously not a concern for them.
Mr. Bonn was asked to describe the intent for
the lot width and area of the heritage home.
It will be on a 23m frontage and 1080 sq m area. The By-law in City View requires a minimum
lot width of 19.5m and area of 600 sq m.
This is a large house with a new proposed garage. This is not a sufficient piece of land to
frame the house as it deserves to be.
Additionally, this heritage house will be hidden from
the public. On Withrow, there are
plans to build four houses and then in behind these there would be an additional five houses in a row (i.e. staggered). The view of
the distinctive heritage house from Withrow would be
The access road from St. Helen’s will be a private road with no parking such
that access can be restricted by residents of this proposed elite subdivision.
Mr. Bonn was asked about residents
having adequate access to parks. He
states that the staff report states that City View has adequate parks. Please see #3 below for more details.
Mr. Bonn was asked if there was any
thought to selling to the community or partners for public use. It was stated by legal representative, Emma
Blanchard, that Joey Theberge has not foreclosed on the prospect
of selling it but wants to move forward.
There is no magic number yet, because contrary to Planning
Department documents, Mr. Theberge does not yet own this
There has been work done on a local
levy. After visiting almost half of the
residents in City View, there was a 70% agreement for the levy. There are other
supporters who have donated money towards the capital cost of this purchase. Funds also exist in the Cash-in-lieu of
Parkland Funds both by Ward 8 and City-wide and the annual OLG park funds.
made by Jennifer
A question was asked about the
calculation of any deficit in parkland in City View.
The response was that there was no
calculation. The statement made by Ms.
Shepherd was that she did
not have the calculation with her at the
time. Ms Shepherd is well aware of this deficit.
The Executive of the City View Community Association have met and
discussed with Ms. Shepherd about this very issue.
Ms. Shepherd then diverted from the given question by stating that there are 7 parks
within 1.5 km from 21 Withrow. She has used this flawed analysis
previously, and we have corrected her, but she made no mention of this.
There are so many things wrong withMs
1.5km is the radius. Thus making a trip to the park a 3km journey
Ainsley Park is not in City View but
is located across Baseline, the future site of Rapid Transit.
Ryan Farm Park is in the community
of Ryan Farm
Gilbey Park is located across
Merivale Road. Merivale Road is the
nightmare of traffic and will increase the amount of traffic because of
intensification plans along that road.
Palsen Parkette is located in Crestview Community, across Meadowlands Road.
Meadowlands is the road used for cut through traffic and is a speedway
That leaves three parks in City
View. ( *SEE attached City View Parkland Deficiency November 2019)
Executive of the City View Community Association has previously asked Ms
Shepherd to remove Bassano Park from the list.
It is a strip of land directly under the Hydro towers, one block in
width. There are no benches and no one
has ever been able to use this strip of land for recreational purposes. (*See attached
Shepherd also included the Nepean Museum in her calculations of the Doug Frobel
Park. The Nepean Museum is NOT included
in the Doug Frobel Park. Also, the
baseball diamond is for the exclusive use of East Nepean Baseball.
The Planning Report for 21 Withrow Avenue Development states (Page
7) that “it was determined that this area had adequate access to various
types of park and open space areas.”
This is completely false and very offensive to the City View Community,
and hides the fact that this development puts us significantly further into
Ms. Shepherd was then asked if there
was any criteria that the City looked at to buy this land in partnership with
the Community. She responded that they did
consider this possibility as this plan seemed
to progress. According to her
comments, it was deemed that the costs of rehabilitating the heritage house, running it and
managing the property were prohibitive. This prohibitive amount has been taken
from the estimated cost by the developer to demolish the inside of the house
and the garage and to modernize both. The Kilmorie Heritage Society has
explored the cost of restoring the house, as in Billings Estate. This could be covered by applications for available grant
money from all levels of government for this purpose.
The issue here is the land. The supporters of this arts
and cultural hub have signed up to give in-kind hours
to restore and maintain the lands and gardens
at Kilmorie and generous donations of native and heirloom plants have
been made. The cost for this would not be
When questions were posed about the heritage
Coutts, City of Ottawa Heritage Department, quoted the Ontario Heritage Act
designation. She said that the intention
was to have a parcel of land to protect and honour the cultural heritage of the
house. How is this achieved when the
house will be hidden from view from Withrow Avenue and only accessible from a
small private road into this elite subdivision? It is the intention of the developer that this heritage house will
become someone’s private home. The fact
that this historically significant house will be invisible and inaccessible to
the public because of its physical situation
and private ownership, is clearly opposite to the intent of the Ontario
Ms Coutts said that staff never had
any intention to include the land with the
Ms Coutts said that her staff
analyzed the history of the land and concluded that since the farm went to 5
acres and then to 2 acres, there was a huge loss of the original property. Then she proceeded to say that there was so much loss of land
that staff felt that the designation of the house was sufficient to honour the
house in the community and saw no need to include the entire parcel of land. This is an argument to save the land that is
left, not lose it to development.
This was the same Ms. Coutts who stated to a Board member of the Kilmorie Heritage Society that
William Wilfred Campbell was not of any historical significance since he didn’t
even have his picture of a stamp.
William Wilfred Campbell was declared a Person of National Historic
Significance in 1938 by the Government of Canada.
Ms. Coutts is the
same City official who told the Executive of City
View Community Association at a meeting with her, that if the Association applied for
heritage status for the land, the application would remain at the bottom of her
Ms. Coutts remarks were inappropriate and
The Kilmorie Heritage Society would like an opportunity to meet with the City staff. It
is our view that the staff working in the various
departments at City Hall, should give the
people in the communities a chance to be heard.
This is part of the vision of the City for the new Official Plan. If
we have to wait until the consultations on the new Official Plan, the
opportunity to resolve the future of this historic site will undoubtedly be
lost. Will our elected officials and the
staff who mandated to serve the citizens of Ottawa’s communities ever really
listen to the people?
Planning Committee meeting of November 14, 2019, and the decision made by this
Committee was based on incomplete and erroneous information.
we are requesting the matter not be forwarded to the November 27th Council
meeting until all the issues have been addressed in an open and transparent
President, Kilmorie Heritage
President, City View
Attachments: City View
Parkland November 2019
PART A: INTRODUCTION &
The City of Ottawa’s Official Plan set a target of 4.0 ha of total
greenspace for every 1000 residents.
It is stated that this target has been achieved throughout most of the
(Greenspace is defined as natural land, open space and leisure land)
*NOTE: 1 ha = 10 000 sqm
The City of Ottawa’s Greenspace Master Plan
(2006) set the standard ratio of parkland to residents at 2 ha of parkland per
Yet in City View the actual
ratio of parkland per 1000 residents is:
of the parkland that we should have.
Bassano Park and Doug Frobel Baseball Diamond are excluded (see Part B) the
actual ratio of parkland per 1000 residents
the parkland we should have
This places City View at the
second lowest ratio of parkland in the City of Ottawa
PART B: BY THE NUMBERS
There are 3 parks
listed in City View:
1. City View Park
Area = (46m x 83.3m) + (13m X 32.5m)
3831.8 sqm + 422.5 sqm
View Park has an area of: 4254.3 sq m = 0.43 ha
2. Doug Frobel Park
Area = 60m X 125m =7500 sq m =.75 ha less .07* =.68 ha
NOTE: The area
of the Nepean Museum Building has been removed from the total area as it is not
Area = (16m x 37m) + (9m x 15m) = 592 sq m + 135 sq m
= 727 sq m = .07 ha
NOTE: The Doug
Frobel Baseball Diamond should not be included, since it is used exclusively by
the East Nepean Little League. It is not
available to the community residents for any other sports or activities. This land is not a shared community
space. 60 m x 60 m = 3600 sq m. = .36
Park has an area of:
3173 sq m =
0.6773 or 0.68 ha (if baseball diamond is
3. Bassano Urban
** This should
NOT be listed as a park. This city
designated parkette is located under the Hydro towers, has no benches nor
equipment. There is no signage and most
of the community think it is private property.
has an area of:15.3 m x 57.4 m= 878.22 sq m
= .09 ha
According to the Greenspace Master Plan, set in
2006, the City of Ottawa standard ratio of parkland to resident is:
ha per 1000 residents
Using the statistics from mid 2018, Ward 8 has a
population of 51 828 and has 22 288 households.
Therefore there is an average of 2.32 residents per household.
City View has approximately 1400
Therefore City View has approximately 3255 residents. This does not include the 180 residents living at City View Retirement Residence on Meadowlands or the high density number of residents living in the Minto buildings on Baseline.
The City of Ottawa standard ratio of parkland to
1000 residents = 2 ha
Therefore CITY VIEW SHOULD HAVE:
6.51 ha of parkland for 3255
also look at the Ratio of households to parkland.
According to the City of Ottawa standards:
households = 1 ha parkland (10 000 sq
households = 4.67 ha parkland (40 000 sq m)
Either way, we are definitely lacking parkland.
PART C: CONCLUSION
The community of City View is significantly lacking parkland. This community is growing due to infill
and intensification. Many
new homes are bought by young families.
These children will grow up, not having the accessibility to community
parks. City View is not like other planned areas In the
City. The roads and garden lots were established in 1913, well before there
were any policies for parks, natural areas or green space. Since the 1970’s the
community association has been trying to rectify this. In fact, in November
1977 the community identified this property at 21 Withrow for protection and
preservation and recommended it for augmentation as parkland. (City View Tomorrow, dated November 1977 and
the subsequent City View Greening Report.
“The role of the park is not just as a compensatory blast of
nature, quiet and calm and oxygen in a city with too little of all of them, but
also as a jointly savoured event, a common currency, something possessed by
everyone, but owned by no one.”
-Frank Bruni, New York Times
Cities are where most Canadians choose to live, work and play. Parks are
“green engines” that help address nearly every issue cities face from
health to food security, from public safety to community cohesion.
More than ever, parks are at the centre of public life. -Park People
The families and seniors in City View need park
space. They need a place that they can
spend quiet time, listen to children’s laughter, make new friends and meet
WHAT CAN WE DO TO SOLVE THIS LACK OF PARKLAND?
The City of Ottawa needs to save the greenspace
at 21 Withrow. This is the last
available greenspace in City View. Once
greenspace is developed, it is lost forever.
Let’s think about the future and protect scarce greenspace.
The community of City View is working hard to
make this a reality. They have
approached all levels of government.
They have received private donations to help with this cause.
Please help us save 21 Withrow!
Posted inUncategorized|Comments Off on Kilmorie – last chance for fairness ad justice
There will be a rental housing study consultation on student housing, that is to be held on May 29th, 6:30- 8:30pm at Ben Franklin Place. Although this is not the main meeting on the issue, it will help push things along if people in the community sign up, go, and push our three main points. Councillor Chiarelli is asking this because his office was not notified of this meeting, hence the late notice on our part to you.
Please assist us in reaching out to your community and encouraging residents to attend this consultation, as well as let them know to send an email to email@example.com, stating our three main points.
1) We would like a residential room by-law that keeps a limit on the number of rooms rented out in a residence to 3. 2) Homeowners will be required to allow inspections of their home in exchange for the right to rent out 1, 2, or 3 rooms. 3) That this by-law covers only a tight geographical area around the college. No more than 2 km.
It is also important that we discourage people from trying to make too many other points, as maintaining consistency around this issue will be key to the success of reaching our goals of obtaining stricter by-laws.
Not far from busy Merivale Road is a familiar landmark on the edge of the City View community. This beautiful cathedral like property, 21 Withrow Avenue, has a fabulous home built in 1842 of locally quarried stone.
In 2015 the last resident Dr. D. Roger passed away and the property was put up for sale by his family. They had applied for a demolition permit which they withdrew once the community and the City worked to have the house declared heritage. We, the community, are still fighting to declare this early farmland heritage designation also.
A developer, Theberge Homes, has a conditional offer on the property and has been planning an elite subdivision. Most of the over 100 trees are slotted to be destroyed. This subdivision planning shows a total disregard to many of our bylaws and the City View Community Association, our Community and interested supporters who have been opposing this development.
We need your help! We are collecting donations to strengthen our plea to City Council to purchase this property. We have an excellent proposal to create a Canadian Poetry Centre, along with a passive place for people to enjoy nature and the gardens. It will be there for our future generations
Below you will find some “Did you know” facts that may surprise you about 21 Withrow Ave. You will also find a link to our Community web page where you can find a wealth of information along with instructions on how to donate or pledge to help save this incredible historic site. Tax receipts will be issued by the City of Ottawa. If this does not move ahead, all monies will be refunded
DID YOU KNOW…….
The Merivale district was known as the “Back Bush” because of the bush terrain that enveloped it. This area is where many Irish immigrants settled and established productive farms with fine farm houses. Many of our founding families were settlers here (Hoopers, Nesbitts, Boyds, Scotts…)
City View is the oldest municipal property in Eastern Ontario and the site of some of the earliest settlements in Ontario. It became a separate geographical identity from Merivale when it received its name in 1890. City View became the largest Police Village in the county.
21 Withrow Ave was one of the original farms along the Merivale Corridor. Pioneer Archibald Scott built “Kilmorie” 125 years before City View grew around it. This beautiful house was built with locally quarried stone in 1842. There are many architectural features that are specific to this time period.
The Scott family donated a parcel of land to the Experimental Farm. This parcel of land is along Baseline Rd and bound by Merivale and Fisher. It is still marked by the distinct pencil-like red posts with white tips.
The Scott family lived at 21 Withrow until the early 1900’s when they sold the farm to William Wilfred Campbell who named it “Kilmorie House”.
William Wilfred Campbell belonged to the renowned group of The Confederation Poets. He was hired by Sir John A. Macdonald to work in the Civil Service in 1891 and earned $1.50 a day. Campbell had transferred from Railways and Canals to the Department of the Secretary of State in 1892, obtained a permanent post in the Department of Militia and Defence in 1893, and then moved in 1897 to the Privy Council Office. In 1908 he would finally find a suitable niche in the archives branch in the Department of Agriculture.
For W.W. Campbell, Kilmorie was his refuge. At Kilmorie, “Where the woods are scarlet and gold”, Campbell entertained kindred spirits as youthful Mackenzie King, Caldwell, who is a friend of City View, and Tait, who still remains Canada’s greatest sculptor.
Campbell and his poems are a part of Canadian History. There was skating at the Governor-General’s party even though it was dangerous at this time of year. Henry Albert Harper, Mackenzie King’s friend and roommate, died trying to save a young girl from drowning in the Ottawa River. Mackenzie was so touched by Harper’s heroism that he later dedicated the statue of Galahad, located at the bottom of Parliament Hill on Wellington Street, to Harper. Campbell wrote a touching poem that effectively captured the country’s reaction to the incident.
Kilmorie serves as a reminder of the area’s agricultural history. It is one of Ottawa’s oldest surviving houses, built 13-23 years after the Bytown Museum building, the oldest surviving stone house in Ottawa.